Emailing a Sexaholic—Part 2
Last week I shared about some emails between Matthew, who is a part of Sexaholics Anonymous, and me. Go here to read the earlier post and here for the email exchange.
The Gospel message is one of transformation, not recovery.
Here are some additional observations that relate to this dialogue:
Defining Lust My experience and strong conviction is that gaining a clear understanding of what lust is goes a long way in helping us to overcome it. The SA “White Book” describes lust as “an attitude demanding that a natural instinct serve unnatural desires” (p. 40). SA also often describes lust as a disease and (based on Matthew’s comments) as sin.
Lust is sin and instantly recognizable. It is hard for me to look at it any other way. Here is the definition that I like: Sexual lust—the illicit sexual buzz—is a willfully allowed pleasurable gratification of wrongfully directed sexual desire that takes place deep inside. Because lust is sin, it enslaves us if we continue in it, just as Jesus taught (John 8:34).
Sexual sobriety SA describes sexual sobriety this way: We are sexually sober when we have no sex outside of a traditional, legal, heterosexual marriage, no sex with self and progressive victory over lust. I love the clarity in that.
However, the term, “Sexual Sobriety,” has a problem. It is used in many different ways by different groups and teachers. It can mean whatever we want it to mean. Most often sexual sobriety refers solely to visible behavior without including anything like the concept of “progressive victory over lust” that SA emphasizes.
I prefer “victory over lust” as a better way to describe the same outcome that SA is describing. It is what God expects from his children.
Sexaholic Even though Matthew gives a good, reasoned defense of this term, it troubles me. “Sexaholic” points to sex. The real problem is—as SA agrees—lust. Doesn’t calling oneself a sexaholic seem defeatist? All of us have sinned, but our identity is not found in sin once God has redeemed us and made us His children. As we deny sinful lusts (Titus 2:12) and walk in the Spirit, sin loses its power over us—we become freed in Christ. We are able to live in victory and leave our sins behind.
Recovery The Gospel message is one of transformation, not recovery. What good place have we been that we hope to recover to? I suggest—instead—walking in victory.
Christ and the Cross Victory over lust came to me as a direct result of obedience to God’s Word. Jesus has forgiven me, set me free and empowered me to live in Him (see Colossians 2:13-15). To that end, I have described an action plan with fourteen weapons that anyone can follow, based fully upon Scripture. Matthew argues that the twelve steps of SA match up well with the fourteen “weapons” that I describe. This is not clear to me. I also am uncomfortable with referencing a “higher power” when our gracious Father has revealed Himself so clearly and powerfully.
Joining with others This is where SA shines. Lust is an isolating sin. It drives us apart from God and others. The best way to overcome lust is with the help of others. In Matthew’s story you see an example of how SA met this need.
My book, Overcoming Lust, is designed to assist in one-on-one discipleship and accountability, an approach that worked well for me.
Note: Matthew’s emails are detailed and speak to the above issues. I encourage you to consider his thoughtful comments and to add your own, below.








Jim, once again a good post; I believe that these definitions will be helpful to many people. However I believe you have a blind spot! By the way you ask the questions you are creating a conflict that does not exist! You’re asking this question, “The Gospel message is one of transformation, not recovery. What good place have we been that we hope to recover to?”
My answer is this: One does not recover “to” anything. One only recovers “from” something. Does someone recover to bankruptcy? Or does one recover from bankruptcy? Once someone declares bankruptcy, this becomes a permanent fact of their financial history. However, if they look at the thinking and habits that brought them to that place, they could learn from their mistakes. They could then learn new ways of thinking and develop new habits so that they do not repeat the past. If they did these things they would recover from bankruptcy, find victory over the destructive characteristics of following old habits, and they would be transformed by the renewal of their thinking. One could find help with this by calling on professionals, or one could find help by talking to others who have been through the process before. This process is called recovery, it can also be called victory, and it could also be called transformation. Recovery looks back at what you are recovering from. Victory looks to the present and future success of different thinking, and the entire process in one of transformation.
It would be a mistake to set up these terms as being in competition with one another, or to suggest that one excludes the other. That would be like saying that our salvation is reconciliation, but not redemption. While redemption and reconciliation speak of different things, one does not exclude the other. They are “inclusive” terms not “excusive” terms.
You also ask, “Doesn’t calling oneself a sexaholic seem defeatist?” My answer to that is: If someone declared bankruptcy, would this be defeatist? It might seem like they are declaring defeat at first, but it would only be defeatist if you remained in the same mistaken thinking and actions that lead one to bankruptcy in the first place, ultimately leading you there again. Recovery, whether from bankruptcy or lust, seeks to interrupt that cycle and begin the process to victory and transformation.
Let me ask you this: Is it better to declare bankruptcy and begin a painful process of recovery with new thinking and new behaviors leading to victory; or would it be better to deny there is a problem and to continue in your old thinking and ways? Which would lead to the greater defeat?
Calling yourself a sexaholic is merely accepting that there is a problem with lust, and that you recognize the problem and are looking for help with it. Using that term is only a reminder of where we have been and do not want to return. This is a Biblical principle; to remember from where we are fallen and change. (Rev 2:4-5; Eph. 2:10-13)
You are actually making the term “sexaholic” mean more than it really does. For those of us who use it, it is simply a recognition that we are with likeminded people with a similar problem with lust, and is a reminder of where we have been, not where we are going. Where we are going with recovery is, with God’s help, to victory by way of the transformation of our thinking. (Rom. 12:2)
I would like to add one more thing to this response. 12 Step programs are merely support groups. They are not religious organizations that teach doctrine, nor are they counseling, therapy, or treatment of any kind; although there are in-patient (rehab) programs that use the 12 steps by permission from A.A.; support groups themselves make no medical claims. They are God honoring and faith friendly support groups.
AA Tradition Two states, “For our group purpose there is but one ultimate authority – a loving God as He may express Himself in our group conscience.”
12step groups believe in God, but they teach no doctrine about God; they leave the
details of faith up to every individual’s own conscience. If you participate ina 12 step program you do well. If you believe in God you do well. However: Jesus said, “You
believe in God, believe also in Me.” (Jn.14:1) For it is God who sent Him (Jn. 12:49), and Jesus says, “I am the way, the truth, and the life. No one comes to the Father except through Me. (Jn. 14:6) Jesus also said, “I tell you the truth, everyone who sins is a slave to sin. (Jn. 8:34) Believe in Jesus, “Then you will know the truth, and the truth will set you free.” (Jn. 8:32)
If you are held in bondage to lust you will find that the 12 steps can offer you sobriety
and recovery, and in this you will do well. But if you want complete freedom and victory from this bondage, place your faith in Jesus also. The 14 weapons
for victory which are found in the book Overcoming Lust, are great tools to use
to find that victory.